my 2 cents is this
all scents work when everything is JUST right, and when there not they don't work or worse they actually scare and keep deer away!
I played with all sorts of scents for yrs, from SAME day fresh scents, syn one's to ???? I spent WAY more money on scents over a 20 yr period than I would like to recall, and in the end, I killed way more BIG bucks using NONE, play the wind, stay as scent free as you can be, and hunt where the deer are
there is NO magic in a bottle, its a waste of $$ IMO
BUT if buying and using it makes you feel better and hunt more, have at it??
as anything that gives you confidence is not a 100 % bad thing!
then again if its scaring deer off you never see(there noses are pretty good you know) ???
HUMM double edge sword again?
HAHA!