Well I think this is going to be a very hard question to answer
Due to the fact, I don't think many folks on open forums really know each other that well
And to be honest, I personally believe that most hunters that manage to kill a BIG buck yr after yr, odds are they are hunting some private lands they either manage or is just super limited hunter access?I say this because I personally find that guys that are really into deer hunting, tend to make the effort to get there own land or find prime spotswhere they have some control over, not having people just walk in and ruin there huntsI know I do in my home state, and many other states I have hunted? Personally, the days of, well, just having the skills to go in cold and come out regularly with a big buck, just ain't out there much TV shows ruined that I think taught folks more or less that to be successful you need private lands and food plots, and to a point, it works great if you do!
And why so few hunting shows take place on public lands, just harder
I honestly feel many folks that hunt public lands or just large forested lands, and kill deer on a regular basis, have more skills, due its to me harder hunting
So who is a better hunter on a web site?? Loaded question with far to many un knowns to pick one to me
Lots of successful hunters, sure, but who's the Best??
I couldn't even make a fair guess
Just my 2 cents