forestman, I had a professional hunter tell me about the Lucky Buck a few months ago, and says he swears by it (not something he is affiliated with either BTW). He did say that the sweeter smell seemed to keep the bigger bucks away for some time, but eventually they came around and are now frequent flyers. I may give that a try next year, but I couldn't be happier with the results from the TR that I have got this year. Good luck!