Went shed hunting yesterday...Found 5 dead deer

Well as many of you know I take pride in my honey hole. I have taken a couple of our members along for a hunt or two...well yesterday I thought, I have not been there to shed hunt this year so I had to make the tough agonizing decision to stay at work or hit the woods and hitting the woods won. For the guys who have not seen pics of my hunting valley, it is one wooded thick and thin valley surrounded by a clover infested field and two other alfalfa fields, then the valley runs back into the woods and beyond....a couple of pics of the valley for your review. First two pics are half way through the valley on the top side, third pic is down in the bottom of the valley farthest point into the woods which is huntable....a rich doctor who would prefer to feed than kill wild animals which is fine with me...no hunters back in there behind my last pic here
Attachment 10070Attachment 10071Attachment 10072

Now that we have the view out of the way. There is one spot which is the furthest northern part (no pic) of the valley before it ends into the alfalfa fields and the last 150 yards, about half of that is THICK. This is the area where the deer love to bed. Well I searched the entire property on foot, even along the fences separating fields, everywhere and did not find one horn. I was ok with that but it was strange is when I worked my way through the thickest stuff to get down in the open area of the thicket I found a massacre, I do not know what hit these deer, bones everywhere I looked. I was distraught and terribly confused. I immediately began my own investigation within my mind....all the bodies were there, all the heads were there except for one. Some together, some apart. I was piecing together bones to figure out how many deer here. Well I found 5 total, dead deer within a 13 yard area, yes I ranged it. I was devastated to find this and I still am. I have in my mind what I believe happened but not sure......maybe a pack of yotes got them surrounded, I just do not know. Would love to hear from you guys on this. These deer were not here the first week of January. I walked through this same spot at that time.

Attachment 10073Attachment 10074

More dead pics, it wouldn't allow me to post all the pics in the original thread post. here they are
Attachment 10075Attachment 10076Attachment 10077Attachment 10078Attachment 10079

PTWM,
First of all it looks as though you have one heck of a nice huntin spot. You're very fortunate and I'm a little jealous.

As far as the dead deer go, by looking at the pics it appears to me that they were not all killed at the same time. The reason I say this is because the carcasses/bones are all in different stages decay. Some of the bones look older with green moss growing on them and no hair around them while in the last pic you can see hair all around the body including still attached to the flesh near the hoof.

Is it possible that this could be a neighbor or poacher dumping site?

If not, maybe an EHM outbreak?

It would take one huge pack of coyotes to take down 5 deer all at the same time in the same place.

Either way its a shame that happened, especially in your honey hole!

One word. Yotes. Most deer head for water when hurt or ill, but that doesn't seem to be the case here. Coyotes are more capable than most give credit for, but I have seen it happen where I hunt. I have found piles of deer bones like that, among other critters. That is likely where they drag to feed.

I suppose it's possible someone may be piling poached deer there, but heads would be gone. Start hunting the yotes.

2-3 weeks could easily yield that many deer from coyote kills if it is a larger pack.

well I too don't think coyote's will group up enough tp bring down 5 deer that close to each other, and keep them there and kill all of them
thats a pretty big task
and if you had that many coyote in your area you would be finding a ton of dead der all over, and fwe live one's on your lands
NOT saying its impossible, just to me not likely
that being said
IF I had to guess , I would almost say maybe someone poisoned them, lots of folks hate deer, and its not terrible uncommon to have a person feed them something bad
and that can even happen to folksd meaning good
corn can go bad, and actually kill a deer if they eat enough of moldy corn off a bait pile
and well, in winter deer do yard up(also a reason making a coyote kill being lower odds, they tard up for protection!)
so to me , I say thats a higher odds deal, they all ate together, maybe a family group, and all ate the bad food, and thus??
NOW EHD or something else is possible too, but normally again you find a lot more dead deer in the area
IF your good with your state game dept, you can call them and ask them, they might be able to test the remains?
or might even know of a neighbor that has a MAjor issue with deer/crop damage, and a dis ike of deer
odds are these folks have complained to the state many times before acting out!
that's my guess/suggestions
and sorry,
it sucks I am sure

I just want to make sure that what I said was clear. I don't believe a large pack of coyotes cornered and killed 5 deer in one night.

However, it is very plausible that a pack of 3-5 coyotes killed 5 deer over the span of 2-3 weeks, especially in thick areas where deer can't escape as quickly. I see coyotes circle around deer to prey on all the time, and its a chore for the deer to get away unscathed, most especially when there are 2-3 coyotes hunting together. Much less january-march when coyotes are mating and need the protein to roam about in the cold snow and ice.

As far as natural causes, the above is what I believe happened. It is entirely possible that poaching/dumping/poisoning happened as well. If they were poisoned, I would suspect you should find dead coyotes, crows, vultures, opossums, racoons, etc. in the area as well.

I think we need to look at the impact of coyotes a little deeper. They are well ahead of wild hogs in terms of sheer numbers. Just because you don't see them doesn't mean they are not there. It is not that common for me to get trail cam pics of coyotes, but each time I go coyote hunting I see no less than 4, and often more. One evening I saw 9 different coyotes in less than an hour and that covered about 200 acres that I could see. The area I hunt is surrounded by land untouched and very thick in areas just as mentioned in this scenario.

I just suggest you take a deeper look into your coyote numbers, that's all.

well I would like to add, that , over the yrs I have known farmers that poisoned deer, and to be honest, other animals didn't really eat the bait like the deer did, if they ate moldy corn, a bird or other smaller animal might not eat as much as a deer would to impact it, and a bird might fly far a way before dying
I don't disagree coyotes will for sure kill more than one deer, but the odds of it being in the same spot to me is very evry odd, deer learn where bad spots are after a few things spoil an area
and to be honest I have the oppisite effect on coyote sightings
when i hunt them I see less than when I am deer hunting or in trail cam pois
last weekend I spent 34 hrs hunting them, and only seen two, one too small to shoot, and one big one but ran at the farmers house not giving me a safe shot!
it was a 2.5 day coyote contest, has 36 grand in the pot too!
so didn't get to kill a one!
there sure smart critters if my eye's

From the pics that you posted I would say you have deer that died at different times/years. I know you said you were just through there recently in January, however the living and dying grass that's grown up around the spine in one picture and the mildew/moss growing on some other bones tell me they've been a while (like Sully's observations). Before I would go to any conspiracy theory of mass poisonings I would look at the likely hood of you having a case of EHD at some point with the possibility of a yote kill there on the skeleton with the rib cage still intact. I would venture to say though, that one likely was during the fall as there is no sign of hide even left, perhaps a hunter's kill that got dumped and perhaps drug to the bottom. How far away from water/stream would these be??

Well all is good observations. Gives me a little insight. Holla this is location about 50 maybe 60 yards from that stream. After reviewing now, yes they do look like they are from different times (maybe 3 time frames). My thoughts are no one purposely poisoned these deer. In the pic of stream, I said the land behind me was huntable......I meant it is not huntable. That is the drs land behind me and he loves deer, he might even have them named. Then the farmers, not in them to do anything purposely. This entire block is a few miles distance around this block. The farmers outside of this block, the other side of the road let their buddies and myself if I wanted to hunt but like I said in earlier threads, there are only two or three small plots within this block who are allowed to hunt the small 5 to 10 acre plots. There is approximately ahhh 400 acres on the block. Where this valley is, right behind my friends house, the dead deer, 25 yards from his back yard line, if a poacher was dropping, it would not be there. He would have to come in from the back side which is a couple thousand yards or so. more so. Drop point, definitely ruled out. EHD I don't know. I am starting to believe that yotes are the cause. They are around there. One or two of these deer could have been wounded and this is a spot that the deer absolutely love and ran there. I have in the last 4 years I have stalked the valley and shot at 3 bedding monster bucks all well over 150 right at the very spot where these bones are. The beds are are thick here. I think I might learn the ins and outs of yote hunting and may go give it a try. I have found dead deer 500 yards off the road back in that the back quarter were being eaten and the deer gone the next day. 100% yote kills. Any experts on yote hunting?